10 Best ‘A Christmas Carol’ Movie Adaptations, Ranked According to IMDb

Charles Dickens‘ 1843 novella A Christmas Carol is a timeless traditional — the fixed retelling of which has warmed households’ hearts by the Christmas Eve fireplace. The story has every thing: musings on charity, redemption, and household wrapped in a neat package deal with a festive bow on high.

There are a couple of parts that should be acknowledged in any good re-telling of Scrooge’s story — a stable supply of the enduring line “Bah humbug!” an empathetic Tiny Tim that carries sufficient pathos to heat the coldest coronary heart, a terrifying Marley door knocker, and a “God bless us, everybody” to convey the home down. Advised variously via the ages, some A Christmas Carol motion pictures have answered that decision superbly, whereas others have missed the mark and left audiences colder than Scrooge’s mattress chamber, as mirrored by audiences’ scores on IMDb.

10 ‘A Carol Christmas’ (2003)

IMDb Score: 5.2/10

A Carol Christmas is undoubtedly the wildest model of Dickens’ novella. The Hallmark Christmas movie options Tori Spelling as Ebenezer Scrooge, or on this case, Carol. The ghosts of Christmas Previous and Current are performed by Gary Coleman and William Shatner, respectively.

The Spirit of Christmas But To Come should at all times be probably the most chilling specter – by no means talking, at all times mysterious, and carrying the menace of mortals’ biggest worry: the unknown future. Right here, the Spirit is a chauffeur, stripping away any conventional peril that comes with this character. It is debatable whether or not that is the worst model of the story, or the most effective, as it veers fairly simply into the realm of “so dangerous that it is good.” Clearly, for many followers, it leans extra towards dangerous than good.

Buy on Amazon

9 ‘A Christmas Carol’ (2009)

IMDb Score: 6.8/10

This animated function by Robert Zemeckis presents Jim Carrey within the roles of Scrooge and the Spirits of Christmas Previous, Current, and But To Come. Carrey drew inspiration from Alastair Sim‘s Scrooge of 1951, a traditional efficiency of the character, which additionally holds up in its animated interpretation.

The animation is a visually gorgeous cinematic spectacle, or a minimum of, it was speculated to be. The 2009 adaptation of A Christmas Carol has gone down in cinematic historical past as one of many worst cases of uncanny valley in film. This additionally offers viewers the sense that some sequences are somewhat indulgent due to the artwork division’s have to flex their muscle tissues. A tip of the night-cap to this telling’s Bob Cratchit, who’s simply as cute as a button and voiced superbly by Gary Oldman.

Watch on Disney+

8 ‘Scrooged’ (1988)

IMDb Score: 6.9/10

Setting the story round tv government Frank Cross (played by Bill Murray), there may be a lot that units this comedic interpretation other than its friends. Some vital plot factors of the unique novella are cleverly addressed within the movie inside a movie, and the contemporized model of Scrooge makes a relatable, high-stakes story.

This adaptation has far and away probably the most shifting monologue by a reformed Scrooge, with a name to motion that rouses all viewers to higher themselves, even when in a small approach, as Scrooge has accomplished. Scrooged has among the best performances and interpretations of the Spirit of Christmas Previous, which is wholly distinctive – he is a neurotic, high-energy taxi driver performed brilliantly by New York Dolls singer David Johansen. The whispered “God bless us, everybody” by the non-verbal son of Frank’s assistant is a phenomenal supply of the enduring line that may certainly tug on the heartstrings of even probably the most bitter “bah humbug” viewers.

Watch on Amazon Prime

7 ‘A Christmas Carol’ (2019)

IMDb Score: 7.3/10

The bleakest retelling of the acquainted story is a BBC miniseries extravaganza, which radically re-imagines the story of Scrooge’s villainy, including deeper and darker backstories than every other telling. Opening with a younger boy relieving himself on Marley’s (Stephen Graham) headstone whereas utilizing some alternative phrases is the primary indication that this can not be a family-friendly affair.

This iteration of the story comprises probably the most bone-chilling entrance of Marley, with probably the most terrifying door-handle apparition of any adaptation. The movie additionally offers better stakes to Marley’s trigger, with an actual function to his haunting of Scrooge that units up the story in a different way from every other. For viewers searching for a grittier model of the story, the 2019 present is the right alternative for a dismal vacation season.

Buy on Amazon

6 ‘Scrooge’ (1970)

IMDb Score: 7.5/10

This fun musical movie adaptation of A Christmas Carol options Albert Finney, who was solely 34 years previous on the time of filming, as Scrooge. Scrooge presents its unlucky viewers with a bizarrely flamboyant Alec Guinness as Marley, a rating of excruciatingly repetitive songs, and the identical twisted expression on Finney’s face for the complete two hours.

There is a actually odd extension of the story that follows Scrooge to Hell and is an pointless decision, because the occasions of the night ought to have modified the character a lot ahead of his journey to Hades. Its comparatively excessive ranking on IMDb is probably going owed to the truth that it is all so ridiculous that it in some way works, with its flaws and cheesiness finally ending up being its largest strengths.

5 ‘A Christmas Carol’ (1938)

IMDb Score: 7.5/10

A decidedly slow-paced retelling of Dickens’ traditional, this model proves that even with the best textual content, the joy does not come without cost. Lots of the actors within the extra cheerful roles play them with an unsettling degree of pleasure that’s excessive and fairly disturbing. With many omissions from the unique textual content but additionally containing weird additions, corresponding to Scrooge calling the cops on the ghost of Jacob Marley and an pointless rendition of “O Come All Ye Trustworthy,” the 1938 model of the story is way from good.

Reginald Owens performs Scrooge with predictable gruffness and little nuance, however there’s admittedly a appeal in that very same predictability. Regardless of its imperfections or maybe due to them, time has been type to 1938’s A Christmas Carol, which is now fondly remembered as an entertaining movie and an awesome try at bringing the story to the massive display screen.

4 ‘A Christmas Carol’ (2018)

IMDb Score: 7.5/10

Enjoying all 38 characters, Simon Callow (who is likely to be identified by audiences from Winnie the Pooh: Blood and Honey 2) first carried out this rendition of A Christmas Carol as a reside one-person present, which skilled a number of profitable seasons on London levels. It was then tailored for movie by the BBC, leading to a masterclass in storytelling.

The sparse set, sound, and lighting results add weight to every one used and place all of the onus of translating Dickens’ phrases on the only real performer. This deeply intimate efficiency is fully engrossing and proves how effectively the textual content stands independently with no need heavy-handed bells and whistles. 2018’s A Christmas Carol is a improbable instance of a giant danger that paid off, and whereas it does not hit all of the excessive marks, it is inventive and fascinating sufficient to be thought of among the many greatest.

2018’s A Christmas Carol shouldn’t be obtainable to stream, lease, or buy right now.

3 ‘A Christmas Carol’ (1984)

IMDb Score: 7.8/10

The 1984 rendition of A Christmas Carol was filmed in a largely preserved county city based within the early Center Ages in Shropshire (and, by the way, was the birthplace of Charles Darwin). Scrooge’s tombstone nonetheless lies within the medieval city, and this model makes nice use of the prevailing structure of its historic location.

George C. Scott‘s efficiency of Scrooge shows a refreshing number of colours reasonably than presenting the identical one-note grumpy miser so typically seen. This explicit Scrooge is one among intelligence and even, at occasions, humor, constructing a posh character who’s greater than a mere crank, which is why film buffs take into account it one of the vital definitive diversifications of the beloved story. It is an admirable and early depiction of nuance in Scrooge’s character, justifying the 1984 movie’s excessive rating.

2 ‘The Muppet Christmas Carol’ (1992)

IMDb Score: 7.8 /10

Not lots can go fallacious when mixing the Muppets and Christmas. Sir Michael Caine‘s Scrooge is completely pitched all through, bouncing off his scene-partner puppets with exceptional ease. Caine had remarked that he would play the function as if he have been performing with the Royal Shakespeare Firm – this good alternative reads effectively, retaining the center and soul of the story intact.

A specific excessive level of the fun movie musical is the track carried out with the Ghost of Christmas Current – the uplifting “It Feels Like Christmas” is wealthy with good cheer and key adjustments and will simply enter the canon of annual go-to carols. Exempting Gonzo and Rizzo and omitting a few darker plot factors, the movie stays comparatively true to the unique textual content. With musical numbers by the Muppets that convey pleasure lengthy after viewing and fabulous performances by man and muppet alike, that is A Christmas Carol model that shouldn’t be missed.

1 ‘Scrooge’ (1951)

IMDb Score: 8.1/10

Conventional and usually trustworthy to the unique textual content (with only some additions, such because the Mr. Jorkin storyline) and that includes a beautiful efficiency from Alastair Sim, this rendition of A Christmas Carol directed by Brian Desmond Hurst is extensively believed to be among the best display screen diversifications of the traditional novella.

The performances, music, and lighting in Scrooge all hit the mark, and the particular results are surprisingly well-executed for a movie of its age. Particularly, the interplay out the window between the younger boy and Scrooge on Christmas morning is delightfully carried out, with Scrooge’s pleasure and newfound fondness for the day shining via. It is no marvel the 1951 adaptation is taken into account the easiest amongst followers on the positioning.

Rent on Amazon

NEXT: The Best Christmas Movies of All Time, Ranked