10 Best James Stewart Westerns, Ranked

James Stewart was considered one of Basic Hollywood’s finest main males, starring in a few of the most profitable movies between the ’30s and ’60s. His early roles tended to be healthful everymen, however he successfully redefined himself from the ’50s onward with darker and extra imposing roles in a string of influential Westerns like Winchester ’73 and The Bare Spur. He is thus an excellent instance of a star who reinvented himself because the viewers’s tastes modified, increasing the blueprint for future film stars to observe.

Whilst his characters turned extra morally grey, Stewart remained an icon of American masculinity; thus, he was well-suited for the Western, probably the most American style in cinema. Consequently, Stewart was concerned in a few of the finest Westerns of the Nineteen Fifties and ’60s, lots of which stay watchable and compelling at the moment. These are Jimmy Stewart’s finest Westerns, starting from the comedic to the grim and gritty.

10 ‘Damaged Arrow’ (1950)

Directed by Delmer Daves

“The Bible I learn preaches brotherhood for all of God’s youngsters.” Damaged Arrow tells the story of Tom Jeffords (Stewart), a former soldier who turns into a mediator between white settlers and the Apache folks in the course of the 1870s. After saving the lifetime of an Apache boy, Jeffords meets the chief, Cochise (Jeff Chandler), and begins to know the hardships they face. Regardless of hostility from each side, Jeffords and Cochise try to finish the cycle of violence and distrust.

The movie represented a major step forward for the Western genre. Notably, it was considered one of the earliest Hollywood movies to painting Native American characters with substantial empathy quite than as mere villains to be defeated by noble cowboys. Summing up the film’s themes, one Christian character declares that the Bible “says nothing about pigmentation of the pores and skin.” Plus, it is merely a brisk and well-told story (clocking it at a lean 93 minutes), that includes loads of motion and an pleasing (if barely tacky) romantic subplot.

WATCH on PLEX

9 ‘How the West Was Received’ (1962)

Directed by John Ford, Henry Hathaway, George Marshall

“They left tracks in historical past that can by no means be eroded by wind or rain.” This epic chronicles the westward enlargement of america, utilizing the Prescott household as a story lynchpin. The story is split into 5 segments, directed by three totally different filmmakers, protecting key historic occasions such because the Gold Rush, the Civil Warfare, and the constructing of the transcontinental railroad.

Stewart performs the mountain man Linus Rawlings, who goes on to hitch the Union military. He is joined by a supporting solid chock-full of heavyweights like John Wayne, Richard Widmark, Lee J. Cobb, and Eli Wallach. The characters are both charmingly archetypal or frustratingly two-dimensional, relying on the viewer. The runtime will get just a little tiresome (the film is sort of three hours lengthy), however attractive cinematography, neat historic particulars, and a basic Western fable of excellent vs. evil carry it over the end line. A real basic of the style, How the West Was Received is spectacle filmmaking accomplished proper.

Rent on Amazon

8 ‘Bend of the River’ (1952)

Directed by Anthony Mann

“When an apple’s rotten, there’s nothing you are able to do besides throw it away.” Former outlaw Glyn McLyntock (Stewart) is making an attempt to begin anew as a path information for a bunch of settlers heading to Oregon. Alongside the way in which, he rescues Emerson Cole (Arthur Kennedy), a person with a equally checkered previous. As they attain their vacation spot, the settlers face quite a few challenges, together with treacherous climate, provide shortages, and hostile merchants.

Bend of the River stands out as one of the most violent Westerns, with ethical complexity and glorious pacing. The story is hard and unrelenting, serving up one betrayal and ethical conundrum after one other, and Stewart rises to the event with a suitably hard-edged efficiency. His depth is palpable, significantly when he menacingly tells Cole, “You’ll be seein’ me. Each time you look again within the darkness and also you mattress down for the evening, you’ll marvel if I’m there. Some evening I shall be.” It is a good distinction along with his extra healthful roles.

7 ‘The Man from Laramie’ (1955)

Directed by Anthony Mann

“That is probably the most unfriendly nation I’ve ever been in. Why is all people so sensitive?” Will Lockhart (Stewart) arrives within the small city of Coronado searching for vengeance for his brother’s loss of life. As Lockhart investigates, he turns into entangled in a bitter feud between rancher Alec Waggoman (Donald Crisp) and his son, Dave (Alex Nicol). The Waggoman household controls the city, and their energy battle complicates Lockhart’s quest for justice. Alongside the way in which, he discovers that his brother’s killers are nearer than he thought.

The Man from Laramie was the fifth and ultimate collaboration between Stewart and director Anthony Mann, and it feels just like the work of collaborators who understood each other nicely. Mann’s signature mix of breathtaking Western iconography and emotional battle is current, however he additionally serves up a extra advanced plot with vital thriller parts that play to Stewart’s strengths. The movie can also be visually spectacular; Mann shoots the sweeping landscapes and claustrophobic interiors with equal talent.

RENT on APPLE

6 ‘Shenandoah’ (1955)

Directed by Andrew V. McLaglen

“This struggle shouldn’t be mine and I do not be aware of it.” Shenandoah facilities on Charlie Anderson (Stewart), a Virginia farmer decided to maintain his household out of the Civil Warfare. Regardless of his efforts, the battle inevitably encroaches upon their lives. When Anderson’s youngest son (Philip Alford) is mistakenly taken prisoner by Union troopers, he and his older sons embark on a harmful journey to rescue him. Their experiences drive Anderson to rethink his stance on non-involvement.

Visually, Shenandoah is nothing particular, partially restricted by its period, however the story is considerate and compelling, cementing it as a meaningful anti-war movie. That is most evident in Stewart’s terrific monologue beside his spouse’s grave. “It’s like all wars, I suppose. The undertakers are profitable it,” he says. “Politicians speak quite a bit concerning the glory of it. The troopers, they only need to go residence.” These themes had been well timed, because the Vietnam Warfare was simply getting began.

5 ‘The Bare Spur’ (1953)

Directed by Anthony Mann

“Choosin’ a technique to die? What is the distinction? Choosin’ a technique to stay – that is the exhausting half.” On this one, Stewart is Howard Kemp, a bounty hunter pursuing fugitive Ben Vandergroat (Robert Ryan) throughout the Rocky Mountains. Kemp is pushed by the promise of a $5,000 reward, which he must reclaim his household farm. Alongside the way in which, he reluctantly companions with an previous prospector, Jesse Tate (Millard Mitchell), and a dishonorably discharged soldier, Roy Anderson (Ralph Meeker). Nonetheless, Vandergroat intends to show them towards each other.

This can be a extra psychological Western with sophisticated, morally ambiguous characters whose greatest threats are their greed and mistrust. The various protagonists are complemented by lovely visuals of various landscapes, making it merely a deal with to take a look at. “The desert represents just one a part of the American West,” director Anthony Mann has said. “I wished to indicate the mountains, the waterfalls, the forested areas, the snowy summits.”

4 ‘The Shootist’ (1976)

Directed by Don Siegel

“To place it in a nutshell, you’ve got plum wore us out.” The Shootist tells the story of John Bernard Books (John Wayne), an growing old gunfighter who learns he has terminal most cancers. Going through his imminent loss of life, Books decides to spend his ultimate days in Carson Metropolis, Nevada, the place he rents a room from widow Bond Rogers (Lauren Bacall) and her son (Ron Howard). As phrase spreads of Books’ presence, previous enemies and opportunistic strangers converge, hoping to settle scores or acquire fame from killing the legendary gunslinger.

Stewart has a supporting function as doctor “Doc” Hostetler, who had handled Books’s gunshot wounds years earlier and now confirms his most cancers analysis. Their scenes collectively are tender, with Doc prescribing Books laudanum to ease his ache and suggesting that he may finish his life on his personal phrases quite than by the hands of his sickness. The Shootist isn’t perfect, however it successfully attracts on each Wayne and Stewart’s storied Western backgrounds, lending it a poignant really feel.

3 ‘Destry Rides Once more’ (1939)

Directed by George Marshall

“You shoot it out with ’em and for some cause or different, I do not know why, they get to seem like heroes.” Destry Rides Once more is a comedic Western set within the lawless city of Bottleneck, the place saloon proprietor Kent (Brian Donlevy) guidelines with an iron fist. The city’s corrupt mayor appoints the mild-mannered Tom Destry Jr. (Stewart) as sheriff, anticipating him to be ineffective. Nonetheless, Destry, the son of a well-known lawman, surprises everybody along with his unconventional strategies and sharp wit, and he’s decided to revive order.

Destry Rides Once more is, in fact, fairly dated now, but it surely’s undoubtedly one of many stronger Westerns of its decade, a vigorous and fascinating movie that ably blends motion and humor. It is also a profitable case of the leads being solid towards kind. Stewart’s efficiency is spot-on and considerably boosted his profile, however the true star is Marlene Dietrich because the feisty saloon singer Frenchy, a career-revitalizing function for her.

2 ‘Winchester ’73’ (1950)

Directed by Anthony Mann

“That is the sort of cowtown that wants quite a lot of legislation.” Winchester ’73 follows Lin McAdam (Stewart), who wins a prized Winchester rifle in a capturing contest, solely to have it stolen by his nemesis, Dutch Henry Brown (Stephen McNally). The movie traces the rifle’s journey because it modifications arms a number of instances, affecting the lives of varied characters, together with a Native American dealer, a cavalry officer, and an outlaw.

All of the whereas, McAdam relentlessly pursues Dutch Henry throughout the rugged panorama, decided to reclaim his rifle and settle an previous rating. Stewart is delectably menacing within the half, tapping into his fearsome facet, leading to a imply, sprawling Western with an unusually massive solid of characters. It is jam-packed with story and numerous Western tropes which it polishes up and makes contemporary as soon as once more. For these causes, Winchester ’73 continues to be held in excessive regard, holding a 100% Fresh rating on Rotten Tomatoes.

Rent on Amazon

1 ‘The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance’ (1962)

Directed by John Ford

“Both you get out of city, or tonight you be out on that road alone.” The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance is a poignant story of legislation, legend, and the making of a hero. In a flashback story, younger lawyer Ransom Stoddard (Stewart) arrives within the city of Shinbone with goals of bringing justice to the beleaguered settlement. He quickly finds himself at odds with the ruthless outlaw Liberty Valance (Lee Marvin). When Stoddard is unable to defend himself, native rancher Tom Doniphon (John Wayne) steps in to guard him.

From right here, the narrative expands right into a examine of fantasy versus actuality and the price of heroism within the American West. It is an early occasion of a Western taking a critical eye to the genre’s mythology. Plot-wise, the film drags just a little, but it surely culminates in a fittingly climactic showdown that justifies the burden. It is likely to be probably the most tightly constructed of director John Ford‘s works, but it surely compensated with a heat and easy allure that may’t assist however be infectious.

RENT on APPLE

NEXT: The 10 Best Alan Alda Movies and TV Shows, Ranked