‘The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’ Suffers From ‘Mockingjay’s Biggest Mistake

Eight years after the unique sequence ended, the Starvation Video games franchise returned with The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, which follows President Snow (Donald Sutherland) as a younger man referred to as Coriolanus (Tom Blyth), depicting the tenth Hunger Games, and introducing the one beforehand unknown District 12 victor, Lucy Grey (Rachel Zegler). It is a tall order for a single movie, however Francis Lawrence determined in opposition to splitting the story into completely different installments. After The Hunger Games: Mockingjay was divided, it appears odd not to take action with the prequel, however Lawrence has since admitted that he regretted his choice to make two movies out of the only ebook by Suzanne Collins. Reluctant to make the identical mistake, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes grew to become a stand-alone prequel and suffers for it. The distinction is that splitting Mockingjay interrupted the momentum of the story. Katniss’ (Jennifer Lawrence) arc had already developed over the primary two movies, making it attainable to suit the mandatory elements of Mockingjay‘s story right into a single (admittedly lengthy) movie.

The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is completely different. Giving the backstory of a fancy character, the movie is Coriolanus’ solely probability to be the lead. As Coriolanus turns into extra just like the President from the Starvation Video games, it takes time to indicate the method of his descent into villainy, and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes doesn’t have that. As well as, characters like Lucy Grey and Dr. Gaul (Viola Davis) get much less focus than they need to as a result of the movie is pressed for time. That is additionally true of the horrific recreation, which reveals a distinct facet to the custom earlier than it was changed into a spectacle by the federal government. With a transparent divide within the story when the tenth Starvation Video games ends, it could make logical sense to separate the story. Although a single ebook, the novel has a number of elements offering a pure break because it modifications settings from the Capitol to District 12, however the movie doesn’t reap the benefits of this. The Starvation Video games and the occasions main as much as it could simply fill a film. In the meantime, the conspiracy in District 12 and Coriolanus’ ultimate descent into villainy could be a dramatic finale, finishing the character’s arc with out dragging out the plot unnecessarily.

Coriolanus’ Improvement Wanted Extra Time in ‘The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’

Because the central character, Coriolanus goes on a journey all through the movie, creating from a ravenous orphan with trauma from residing by means of a warfare to a chilly and manipulative chief who does not care how his actions influence others. Actually, Blyth performs the half properly because the movie particulars this transition, nevertheless it should be rushed to suit throughout the roughly two-and-a-half-hour time constraint. Coriolanus’ character arc is not easy as he goes from being in it for himself to creating pals to betraying these pals and carrying out his authentic aim. His disadvantages originally develop sympathy, which has run out by the end. Coriolanus could have the household title, however the Snows are out of cash and depend on his cousin, Tigris (Hunter Schafer). Coriolanus hides this truth, dreaming of getting the prize cash from the Starvation Video games mentoring program to pay for continued training so he can enhance his household’s life. This all appears noble and utterly not like the President, who’s Katniss’ antagonist. This development continues as he befriends Sejanus (Josh Andrés Rivera), who’s seemed down on by the Capitol households for being born in District 2. Sejanus’ compassion pushes Coriolanus in the proper path, as does the affect of Lucy Grey, whom he begins to like.

But the story not solely consists of him creating these friendships however destroying them as properly. He betrays Sejanus to earn favor with Dr. Gaul and tries to kill Lucy Grey (although the jury is out on whether he succeeds). It isn’t till the tip that he reveals indicators of villainy. In truth, at first, his transfer to District 12 appears to push him to be higher. Whereas Katniss did not want two Mockingjay movies to succeed in her ultimate realization about corruption, Coriolanus might have used extra time to be corrupted. He primarily undergoes a number of character arcs as he first chooses Lucy Grey above all the things, serving to her cheat within the Starvation Video games, after which chooses himself by planning to kill her to cover his affiliation with the murders in District 12. Splitting these into separate movies would profit the character, giving the viewers the possibility to study extra about him and empathize with him earlier than he succumbs to his personal egocentric want for energy.

Associated

‘The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’ Easter Eggs

‘The Starvation Video games: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’ references the opposite movies within the sequence always regardless of the big time hole.

‘The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’ May’ve Expanded About A lot Extra

With a solid made up of gifted actors akin to Viola Davis and Peter Dinklage, plenty of characters might have proven up extra. Davis’ Gaul is a major instance, as her terrifying character is liable for a lot of the titular video games. However the character whose time is missing probably the most is Lucy Grey. Although secondary solely to Coriolanus, Lucy Grey doesn’t attain her full potential within the allotted time. The character is the primary Starvation Video games victor to realize the eye of the Capitol residents, like Katniss herself. She is probably not a very expert fighter, however her willpower helps her survive the world. Displaying many skills, Lucy Grey is the pure hero of the story. However the movie speeds by means of many components, and our Victor does not get the eye she deserves. One of many many changes from the book is Lucy Grey’s victory, making it the snakes that kill the runner-up relatively than Lucy Grey manipulating and poisoning him, taking away from her cleverness and willpower to outlive, that are very important to the character. Lucy Grey wanted extra time to develop her relationship with Coriolanus and present what she was actually able to when it got here all the way down to it.

Like Lucy Grey’s victory, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes brushes over among the darker features of Collins’ ebook. Whereas each different Starvation Video games movie that throws the characters into an area spends the vast majority of the time displaying the Starvation Video games itself, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes doesn’t. And this is not as a result of it is centered on Coriolanus, who is not a tribute, however as a result of there’s an excessive amount of story to deal with the Video games. That is the primary glimpse audiences have on the early Video games earlier than the spectacle of the occasion was used to hide its brutality, however the movie does not spotlight that facet of the story as a lot because it might have. Reaper (Dimitri Abold), the Tribute from District 11, takes the time to line up the fallen tributes, giving them respect, much like how Katniss treated Rue (Amandla Stenberg) in her first video games. His monument stays the entire time, as do the our bodies of the useless youngsters. This act is dangerously near revolt, one thing the movie didn’t have extra time to discover, but it proves that others tried earlier than Katniss. The complete idea is darkish, particularly with out the Capitol doing all the things it might to show the Video games into one thing they are not. The brutality through the Starvation Video games did not have the influence it might have if the storyline and the characters had extra time within the highlight.

‘The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes’ Has a Pure Division

Whereas The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes tells one story, there’s a pure place for the movie to be break up: when the Starvation Video games finish and Coriolanus is banished to the Districts. Every other Hunger Games film, apart from Mockingjay (which does not function the Video games), ends with the climactic conclusion of the Starvation Video games, however not The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. As a substitute, that’s solely the primary part of the plot. After Lucy Grey’s victory, there’s a shift within the story. The movie transitions to Coriolanus’ life as a Peacekeeper after his unlawful help of Lucy Grey is found. Not solely is that this a totally completely different journey for Coriolanus, however the tone appears to alter as he enjoys life with Lucy Gray’s Covey family, inflicting a definite and abrupt shift in the midst of the movie. This would offer an ideal place for one movie to finish and one other to start if that they had break up the story in two.

Not utilizing this division is a missed alternative. The Starvation Video games and the occasions main as much as it, the place Coriolanus promoted Lucy Grey to raised her place within the area, would have stuffed a two-hour movie with out challenge. This could have given the story the liberty to raised discover the occasions and the horror of the Video games. Likewise, Coriolanus’ life in District 12 has loads of materials. From the introduction of the Covey to the insurgent exercise, there’s a lot to incorporate as Coriolanus’ arc completes, and he decides to be the ruthless man we had been launched to in The Starvation Video games. Even with out the Video games, this is able to have greater than sufficient motion, as Sejanus is hanged and Coriolanus kills Mayfair Lipp (Isobel Jesper Jones). And it could enable for a extra in-depth exploration of Lucy Grey’s historical past, which will get in the best way as she and Coriolanus start their relationship. Whereas making Mockingjay two completely different films made little sense, protecting The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes collectively wasn’t excellent both. The prequel incorporates an excessive amount of story to suit right into a single movie, proving there are causes to divide a ebook, nevertheless it will not work for everybody.

The Starvation Video games:The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes is out there to stream on STARZ within the U.S.

WATCH ON STARZ